5—What about redistribution?

5—What about redistribution?
Note:5@@@@@@@@@@@@

Yellow highlight | Location: 991

Why eat an ice cream cone when someone in Malawi is starving?
Note:VECCHIA DIFFICILE QUESTIONE

Yellow highlight | Location: 993

our personal obligations toward the poor appear strong.
Note:UTILITARISMO IMPOSSIBILE

Yellow highlight | Location: 994

less than two dollars a day.
Note:SEVERAL BILION PEOPLE

Yellow highlight | Location: 994

millions of children died of preventable diseases such as diarrhea
Note:APRI GLI OCCHI

Yellow highlight | Location: 996

how far such obligations extend
Note:DOBBIAMO AIUTARE CHI STA PEGGIO...MA....

Yellow highlight | Location: 997

In contrast to utilitarianism, common sense morality typically suggests
Note:COMMON SENSE...UTILITARISM

Yellow highlight | Location: 999

Wealthy doctors should spend large parts of their careers, if not their entire careers, in African villages.
Note:SECONDO GLI UTILITARISTI

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,001

Wall Street wizard and then a wealthy philanthropist.
Note:CI SONO MODI ANCORA PIÙ GENIALI

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,002

Are you willing to value the interests of others on par with your own,
Note:SANTITÀ ASSURDA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,003

a mother might have to abandon or sell her baby in order to raise money to send food to the babies of others.
Note:OBBLIGHI UTILITARISTICI

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,006

Most people would instead become a kind of utility slave,
Note:I NUOVI SCHIAVI

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,008

excessively demanding
Note:IL CONSEGUENZIALISMO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,009

Peter Singer, who trumpet the call for greater sacrifice
Note:GLI INTEGRALISTI

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,010

I am a pluralist
Note:MEGLIO L ECLETTISMO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,014

we’ll see that there are some strong and strict limits on our obligations to redistribute wealth,
Note:SE IL FRAME È QS...ANCHE L UTILITARISTA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,015

siding with common sense morality,

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,017

the correct approach to our cosmopolitan obligations does not lead to personal enslavement
Note:L AOUTO È SEMPRE DOVUTO MA...

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,018

Most of us should work hard, be creative, be loyal to our civilization, build healthy institutions, save for the future, contribute to an atmosphere of social trust, be critical when necessary, and love our families. Our strongest obligations are to contribute to sustainable economic growth and to support the general spread of civilization, rather than to engage in massive charitable redistribution
Note:CONCLUSIONI ANTICIPATE

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,022

we should redistribute wealth only up to the point that it maximizes the rate of sustainable economic growth.
Note:IL NS DOVERE

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,029

Other benefits of redistribution stem from political improvements. Social welfare programs can buy the loyalties
Note:Assicurazione

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,030

social welfare programs make many citizens feel better about their state, again boosting public order as well as political consensus and stability.
Note:Cccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,033

we should describe them as investments—and
Note:Cccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,035

an overly generous level of wealth transfer harms economic growth. Many people end up working less,
Note:Attenzione

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,036

if it is standard procedure to approach government for a handout, that will induce too much rent-seeking,
Note:Altro inconveniente

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,038

create urban cultures of dependency and crime,
Note:Ccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,039

non-infrastructure government spending is correlated positively with lower growth rates,
Note:Cccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,041

Excess transfers are bad for another reason, namely that they make it harder to absorb high numbers of immigrants
Note:Ccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,043

resent it when some immigrants receive government benefits.
Note:Ccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,047

rather than redistributing most wealth, we can do better for the world by investing in high-return activities like supporting immigration
Note:Ccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,048

producing new technologies with global reach, such as cell phones

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,048

Many people mock the term “trickle-down economics,” but most social benefits do take a trickle-down form.
Note:Sgocciolamento

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,056

I favor pluralism rather than utilitarianism or common sense morality per se.
Note:Bottom line

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,059

now consider the question of why public and private ethical codes might differ so much in their recommendations.

Note | Location: 1,060

Altra questione da qui

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,060

mother is justified in looking after her own baby rather than selling it to send resources
Note:Nella sfera privata

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,061

Yet in the public sphere, it is widely believed that governments should be more impartial,
Note:Cccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,062

not favor the interests of one particular baby over another,

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,064

But why should morality be so bifurcated?

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,066

This is actually just another application of Adam Smith’s classic principle of the division of labor. It’s easy to see why parents do best when they attend to their family priorities and governments do best when they institute a legal regime based on impartiality and the rule of law.
Note:Adam smith

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,072

the case for redistribution would be stronger if the world were going to end in the near future. If the time horizon is extremely short,
Note:Esempio

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,075

imagine that the world were set to end tomorrow. There would be little point in maximizing the growth rate;

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,082

The attitude of historical pessimism is therefore one of the most important critiques of my arguments.

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,090

Many advocates of greater state spending—especially non-economists—seem to like the idea of a very low discount rate.
Note:Contraddizioni a sinistra... non puoi essere progressista, avere quindi tassi bassi, e voler spendere anziché investire ... per investire bene non devi redistribuire

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,091

like our government to devote more resources to education, to infrastructure, and to improving the environment, all positions associated with the political left overall, at least in the United States. They see a lower discount rate as supporting all of these policies.
Note:Ccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,094

They often favor market-based discount rates, which are relatively high, but when the topic is redistribution, they worry much more about the longer-term consequences.
Note:Contraddizione al contrario a destra... non puoi vedere alti tassi di sconto e non spendere...non puoi essere pessimista e non redistribuire

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,097

A greater orientation toward the future is likely to increase the desirability of policies favoring a market economy, economic growth, and technological innovation.

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,108

Martin Luther King Jr. brought much good to the world
Note:Casi eccezionali

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,108

It would be fair to say that King did the right thing in choosing to pursue higher ideals rather than playing golf all day,
Note:Cccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,114

so it’s not morally clear which individual is obliged to make the sacrifice.
Note:Cccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,118

This becomes a problem of game theory,
Note:Cccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,119

so that it is better if someone makes a sacrifice to achieve a socially valuable end, but it is worse if everyone sacrifices or tries to sacrifice to achieve that end.
Note:Cccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,125

the sacrificers should be the people most inclined to do so.
Note:Si torna al buon senso

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,138

In any case, individuals are more likely to sacrifice too little than too much, and too few individuals are willing to sacrifice much at all.
Note:Legge generale

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,140

We should strengthen our consciences, as well as social norms,
Note:Cccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,143

Should money be redistributed to the rich?
Note:Tttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,145

utilitarianism may support the transfer of resources from the poor to the rich. A talented entrepreneur, for instance, can probably earn a higher rate of return
Note:Controintuitivo

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,148

If we combine the trickle-down effect from the wealth of the wealthy with a zero rate of discount, it is easy to generate scenarios in which utilitarianism would recommend the redistribution of wealth to the wealthy.
Note:Ccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,157

over a sufficiently long time horizon the poor will benefit
Note:Cccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,174

Our obligations to the elderly

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,177

while we should do a good deal to help the elderly, the logic of sustainable growth places limits on these obligations, too.
Note:Spoiler

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,180

“Why don’t we value human lives at replacement cost?”
Note:Poco da vivere

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,182

I’ve been thinking about that question for a long time because it challenges a lot of our moral intuitions.

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,186

So let’s say a human life is worth $4 million,
Note:Esempio

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,187

but we can create another human life for about $10,000, say by subsidizing births
Note:Cccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,190

Virtually all of us would agree that $10,000—it could be even less—is not, in general, an adequate valuation of a life,
Note:Vccv

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,191

the life we would lose and the new life we would create would not be identical.
Note:Primo

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,192

replacing

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,194

Furthermore, failing to save the first life and investing in helping or creating another life are not usually causally related.
Note:Secondo

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,197

Still, replaceability should not be completely irrelevant to how we think about the value of a life.
Note:Ma

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,198

losing an irreplaceable civilization is a much greater tragedy than losing a civilization in a way which allows for the birth of a new and different one in its place.
Note:Civiltà

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,201

additional wealth that accumulates as a result of economizing on life-saving expenditures does lead people to buy safer cars,
Note:Esempi

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,204

this possibility lowers the value of spending a lot of money to extend a human life.
Note:Ccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,208

My arguments therefore suggest a lower estimate of the value of a life, including an older life, than most other plausible frameworks, because replacement and replenishment of the civilizational flow are considered as one factor among many
Note:Bottom

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,211

To put it more concretely, today in the United States we are spending too much on the elderly and not enough on the young.
Note:Cccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,218

Once-and-for-all changes vs. growth rate changes
Note:Ccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,220

such policies may yield some benefit in a once-and-for-all fashion; imagine increasing the power of all light bulbs for one year. Second, the new benefits may be ongoing and self-augmenting; imagine scientific policies that speed up the rate at which better light bulbs (or other innovations) are developed.
Note:Divide

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,226

To consider a simple example, many scientists believe that global warming will increase the number of virulent and persistent storms on our planet.
Note:Esempio

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,228

More generally, many environmental problems hurt our prospects for long-run sustained growth.
Note:Cccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,230

In contrast to the threat of severe and ongoing storms, some of the costs of climate change take the form of one-time adjustments, such as the cost of relocating coastal settlements.
Note:Vcccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,237

The most prominent economic approach to growth, the Solow model,
Note:Tt

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,239

National output is the result of capital inputs,
Note:Cc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,241

In this model, the primary way to increase ongoing growth is to induce a higher rate of technological innovation.

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,243

The Solow model helps us to understand the phenomenon of catch-up growth,

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,243

In the model, the rate of return on capital diminishes as the capital stock increases.
Note:Ccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,256

In contrast to the Solow model, the increasing returns model suggests that growth begets more growth.
Note:Romer

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,257

In this view, larger economies should grow more rapidly than smaller economies,
Note:Divergenza

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,259

Ideas, and their non-rival nature, are often cited as the fundamental source of increasing returns.

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,266

Paul Romer,

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,269

To put these growth theories into my own terminology, the increasing returns model suggests that there are lots and lots of Crusonia plants
Note:Bottom

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,275

The increasing returns growth model will therefore make us more wary of non-growth-enhancing wealth redistribution than will the Solow growth model.

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,280

Individuals who believe in the increasing returns model should be much more skeptical of non-growth-enhancing redistribution than individuals who believe in the Solow catch-