l'utilitarismo è una stronzata

 https://www.facebook.com/riccardo.mariani.585/posts/pfbid0cVL9A3JG9tgcVDQmhYiyNqaNBv3iNVDjnZr7AtQGFBEGzN9Z7PPSAGYPXBzuULZ5l

ANTISCIENTIFICITA' DELL'UTILITARISMO.

Non c'è da stupirsi che facciamo fatica a scoprire come essere felici. I sentimenti di felicità nascono da sorprese positive rispetto alle nostre aspettative. Le sorprese non sono, per definizione, qualcosa che possiamo ottenere in modo stabile e prevedibile nel corso del tempo. L'utilitarista che vuole massimizzare la sua felicità e crede nel suo modello non potrà, incrementarla in alcun modo, così come non potrà incrementare in nessun modo quella altrui senza tornare al punto da cui è partito. Il suo errore di fondo è considerare la felicità come una quantità anziché un indicatore. Noi usiamo la felicità, non vogliamo la felicità. Come ogni cartello segnaletico, una volta che lo abbiamo seguito, possiamo anche buttarlo in pattumiera. La natura ci ha fatto così: vogliamo cose che stanno nel mondo (zuccheri, pelli, status, alleati...), non cose che stanno nella nostra testa. L'utilitarismo quindi è una stronzata. Questo ha conseguenze non da poco: lo stato sociale è una stronzata, la ridistribuzione dei redditi è una stronzata, l'aiuto al prossimo è una stronzata... Quindi il problema si sposta: perché crediamo alle stronzate? E qui si apre un capitolo illuminante.

https://www.optimallyirrational.com/p/the-aim-of-maximising-happiness-is

https://www.optimallyirrational.com/p/unpacking-the-modern-science-of-happiness

la coscienza è un problema di immaginazione

 Sul problema della coscienza.

Facciamo fatica a immaginare la differenza tra 4.000 e 8.000 morti, per questo faremo fatica a sentirci sconvolti con il doppio dell'intensità. Allo stesso kodo, non possiamo immaginare come la nostra esperienza soggettiva possa consistere solo di cellule nervose e sostanze chimiche. Quindi supponiamo che ci debba essere un divario incolmabile tra mente e materia, un regno dello spirito e un regno del fisico. Supponiamo che ci sia un "difficile problema di coscienza", invece di un "difficile problema di immaginazione".

https://www.everythingisbullshit.blog/p/imagination-is-bullshit

la felicità è una stronzate

 https://www.everythingisbullshit.blog/p/happiness-is-bullshit

https://www.facebook.com/riccardo.mariani.585/posts/pfbid02J8CmCCUALErn3KnfrsRa3DN1cPfAX7mf4CFH97f6sfy6vq7cD36ApdhPsjBk7hPcl

esempi

noi vogliamo soffrire

 https://www.everythingisbullshit.blog/p/you-want-to-suffer

cerchiamo la sofferenza perché solo la sofferenza è maestra.

cos'è la libertà

 https://www.everythingisbullshit.blog/p/is-effective-altruism-bullshit

La verità è che non possiamo scegliere cosa vogliamo in ultima analisi: l'evoluzione lo ha già scelto per noi. Ma c'è almeno una cosa che possiamo scegliere: cosa fingere di volere. È lì che risiede la nostra libertà, se esiste una cosa del genere. Se possiamo fingere di volere un mondo migliore e ricompensarci a vicenda per aver finto in modo più convincente dei nostri rivali, allora forse possiamo creare un mondo migliore.

l'altruismo efficace è una stronzata

 https://www.everythingisbullshit.blog/p/is-effective-altruism-bullshit

il senso della vita è una stronzata

 https://www.everythingisbullshit.blog/p/the-meaning-of-life-is-bullshit

Il vero mistero non è il significato della vita, ma perché scimmie come noi si preoccupino del significato della vita. Ecco quattro indizi per risolvere il caso:

1. "Non importa a tutti. Di solito quando chiedi alla gente qual è il senso della vita, ricevi sguardi vuoti, scrollate di spalle o roteazioni di occhi. Solo una piccola manciata di strambi istruiti esprime interesse per l'argomento".

2. "Questi strambi sono molto bravi a ragionare. È così che hanno ottenuto le loro credenziali  impressionanti, ed è così che hanno imparato tutti i termini rilevanti: esistenzialismo, nichilismo, noia, ecc.".

3. "Il ragionamento umano non serve per la contemplazione solitaria: serva a vincere i dibattiti, a giustificarsi, a trovare scuse, a raccontare cazzate e a scoprire le cazzate altrui".

4. "Le vere ragioni dietro al comportamento degli "strambi" sono impresentabili". Perché come il resto di noi sono semplici creature di Dio, in particolare "scimmie spinte dalla paura, dallo status, dal nepotismo, dal tribalismo e da altri impulsi primitivi". 

SOLUZIONE: "Ecco allora perché gli strambi (intellighenzia) si preoccupano del senso della vita.  Cercano una storia sufficientemente vaga e non troppo palesemente falsa da raccontare su se stessi per apparire moralmente e intellettualmente sofisticati, così che altri nerd li elogino come "profondi", "rivoluzionari" e "umani". I dibattiti sul senso della vita sono in definitiva una forma contorta di manipolazione dello status nell'eterna lotta che dispiega questo gioco a somma zero. Altrimenti, per quale altro motivo le scimmie come noi dovrebbero interessarsi al significato della vita?"

la felicità è una stronzata

 https://www.everythingisbullshit.blog/p/happiness-is-bullshit

12 Charity

12 Charity
Note:12@@@@@@@@@@

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,436

If you notice a boy drowning in a shallow pond right in front of you, you have a moral obligation to try to rescue him.
Note:L OBBLIGO DI SINGER

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,439

you have the exact same moral obligation to rescue children in developing countries who are dying of starvation,
Note:LA PARTE COMTROVERSA DI SINGER

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,440

The fact that they aren’t dying right in your backyard isn’t justification
Note:IRRILEVANTE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,443

every time we take a vacation, buy an expensive car, or remodel the house, it’s morally equivalent to letting people die right in front of us.
Note:IMPLICAZIONE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,445

through college in America, you could instead save the lives of more than 50 children
Note:EQUIVALENZA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,447

everyday human hypocrisy
Note:COSA EVIDENZIA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,453

EFFECTIVE ALTRUISM

Note | Location: 3,453

TTTTTTTTTTT

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,455

In 2006, Holden Karnofsky and Elie Hassenfeld
Note:INIZIATORI DEL MOVIMENTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,460

In financial terms, they were looking to maximize their return on investment (ROI)
Note:ANCHE QUANDO SI DONA...ROD RETURN OF DONATION

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,463

Some simply sent glossy brochures with photos of smiling children
Note:LA RISPOSTA DELLE ONLUS

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,464

(Take a moment to consider why a philanthropist might want to keep a “trade secret.”)
Note:LA DOMANDA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,469

in 2007, they decided to leave their jobs and start GiveWell,
Note:ALLA FINE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,478

The Against Malaria Foundation,
Note:CLASSIFICA DI GIVE WELL...1

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,479

GiveDirectly,
Note:2

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,480

The Schistosomiasis Control Initiative,
Note:3

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,481

These are hardly the most popular or paradigmatic charities.
Note:MARAVIGLIA!!!!!

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,482

United Way, Salvation Army, or Make-A-Wish Foundation, for example.
Note:MOLTO PIÙ GETTONATE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,487

ignore charities that try to effect more nebulous (political or cultural) changes.
Note:LA CRITICA A GW

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,490

when we start to look at real-world altruism, helping people efficiently doesn’t seem to be our top priority.
Note:AMARA CONSTATAZIONE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,491

REAL-WORLD ALTRUISM
Note:Tttttttttttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,492

Nine out of 10 of us donate to charity every year.
Note:USA...UN POPOLO GENEROSO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,493

donations amounted to more than $359 billion—roughly 2 percent of the country’s GDP.
Note:NEL 2014

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,517

The striking thing about real-world altruism is how sharply it deviates from effective altruism.
Note:IL FATTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,517

The main recipients of American charity are religious groups and educational institutions.
Note:BENEFICIARI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,520

no more than 13 percent11 of private American charity goes to helping those who seem to need it most: the global poor.
Note:13

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,525

only 35 percent do research on any charitable gift in the course of a calendar year.
Note:L EFFICIENZA CONTA MA NN VIENE CONTROLLATA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,527

•Only 3 percent of donors do comparative research
Note:Cccccccccccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,530

“British people had donated over £1 billion to the Princess of Wales charity, long before the newly established charity had any idea what the donations
Note:DOPO LA MORTE DI DIANA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,533

One study, for example, asked participants how much they would agree to pay for nets that prevent migratory bird deaths. Some participants were told that the nets would save 2,000 birds annually, others were told 20,000 birds, and a final group was told 200,000 birds. But despite the 10- and 100-fold differences in projected impact, people in all three groups were willing to contribute the same amount.
Note:TIPICO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,537

scope neglect or scope insensitivity,
Note:BATTESIMO DEL BIAS

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,540

People also prefer to “diversify” their donations, making many small donations rather than a few strategic large ones to the most useful charities.
Note:ALTRA PREFERENZA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,546

Giving $3,500 to the Against Malaria Foundation will save a whole human life, while the same amount divided across 100 different charities might go entirely to waste,

Note | Location: 3,547

IRRAZIONALE MA ANCHE DANNJOSO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,549

wealthy people often perform unskilled volunteer work (and are celebrated for it), even when their time is worth vastly more on the open market.
Note:ALTRO MISPLACEMENT

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,558

“WARM GLOW” THEORY
Note:Ttttttttttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,561

Andreoni theorized, we do charity in part because of a selfish psychological motive: it makes us happy.
Note:TEORIE ALTERNATIVE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,566

Making automatic payments to a single charity may be more efficient at improving the lives of others, but the other strategy—giving more widely, opportunistically, and in smaller amounts—is more efficient at generating those warm fuzzy feelings.
Note:UN CONFRONTO...ARGOMENTO CHE SPIEGA LA DIVERSIFICAZIONE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,570

why it feels good when we donate to charity.
Note:RESTA UN GAP

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,573

Visibility.
Note:FATTORI CHE INFLUENZANO LA NOSTRA INCLINAZIONE A DARE...1

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,574

Peer pressure.
Note:2

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,575

Proximity.
Note:3

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,576

Relatability. We give more when the people we help are identifiable (via faces and/or stories)
Note:4

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,578

Mating motive.
Note:5

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,580

VISIBILITY
Note:Ttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,581

we give more when we’re being watched.
Note:DI COSA PARLIAMO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,583

people donate significantly more when the solicitor makes eye contact
Note:SIAMO VISTI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,584

People also give more when the solicitor can see their donations,
Note:INOLTRE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,588

That’s why they commemorate donors with plaques,
Note:I FILANTROPI LO SANNO BENE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,592

Even blood donors typically walk away with a sticker that says, “I gave blood today.”
Note:ALTRO CASO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,596

Anonymous donation, for example, is extremely rare.
Note:L 1 PER CENTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,600

“They were well known within their social circle . . . even though their names may not have been splashed across the newspapers.
Note:ANCHE GLI ANONIMI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,606

Not surprisingly, the vast majority of donations to such campaigns fall exactly at the lower end of each tier.
Note:DA 500 A 900 SOCIO... Da 1000 A 2000

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,608

PEER PRESSURE
Note:TTttttttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,610

First of all, solicitation works:
Note:ROMPERE LE BALLE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,611

up to 95 percent of all donations are given in response to a solicitation.
Note:Cccccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,612

In-person solicitations, like when someone comes to your door or passes the collection plate at church, work better than impersonal solicitations
Note:CONTATTO VISIVO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,617

Universities, for example, often solicit donations from alumni by having other alumni from the same class call them up.
Note:UN CASO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,627

PROXIMITY

Note | Location: 3,627

Ttttttttttttttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,629

Remember the drowning boy in Peter Singer’s thought experiment?
Note:UN CLASSICO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,631

Jonathan Baron and Ewa Szymanska call this bias parochialism.
Note:STUDIOSI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,635

only an estimated 13 percent ($39 billion) went to help foreigners.
Note:DONAZIONO USA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,638

We treat close family better than friends, and friends better than strangers
Note:UN TRATTO INELIMINABILE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,640

RELATABILITY
Note:Tttttttttttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,641

we’re much more likely to help someone we can identify—a specific individual with a name,
Note:IDENTIFICATI IDENTIFICATI I ROTAGONISTI...CON UNA STORIA ALLE SPALLE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,644

identifiable victim effect.
Note:BATTESIMO DEL FENOMENO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,645

“A single death is a tragedy; a million deaths is a statistic.”
Note:PAROLA DI STALN

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,649

Liz’s story, perched beneath her bright, beaming smile, is chock-full of personal details.
Note:ADOZIONE A DISTANZA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,655

Contrast this with the Against Malaria Foundation. Although it saves hundreds of lives every year, it can’t offer names or faces of the people it helps, because it saves only statistical lives.
Note:VITE STATISTICHE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,658

there’s no single individual a donor can point to and say, “I saved this man’s life.”
Note:Ccccccccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,660

MATING MOTIVE
Note:Tttttttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,660

the opportunity to impress potential mates.
Note:ALTRO FATTORE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,661

more likely to give money when the solicitor is an attractive member of the opposite sex.
Note:SPECIE GLI UOMINI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,664

psychologist Vladas Griskevicius
Note:SPERIMENTATORE SUL CAMPO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,674

APPEARANCES MATTER
Note:Tttttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,676

Griskevicius calls this phenomenon “blatant benevolence.” Patrick West calls it “conspicuous compassion.
Note:LA NS GENEROSITÀ

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,679

charity is an advertisement, a way of showing off.
Note:IN ALTRE PAROLE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,682

“Take egotism out,” said Ralph Waldo Emerson, “and you would castrate the benefactors.”
Note:LA MASSIMA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,685

To donate with credit in mind hardly seems like charity at all.
Note:RIMOZINE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,689

one of our primary audiences is potential mates.
Note:MA CHI VOGLIAMO IMPRESSIONARE?

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,691

Stinginess isn’t sexy.
Note:Cccccccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,695

Women actively celebrate the generosity of Princess Diana and Mother Teresa,
Note:OBIEZIONE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,696

women who have gone through menopause (and therefore have no mating incentive) are as generous as any other
Note:ALTRA OB

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,698

even when they’re happily married with no chance of having further children.

Note | Location: 3,698

Ccccccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,701

charity serves to impress not just potential mates, but also social and political gatekeepers.
Note:INFATTI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,707

“Why does charity make us attractive to mates, teammates, and social gatekeepers?”
Note:ALTRA DOMANDA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,709

The most obvious thing we advertise is wealth, or in the case of volunteer work, spare time.
Note:COSA OSTENTIAMO?

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,714

Those who are struggling to survive don’t make ideal allies.
Note:XCHÈ

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,715

Charity also helps us advertise our prosocial orientation, that is, the degree to which we’re aligned with others.
Note:ALTRO BENE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,719

This helps explain why generosity is so important for those who aspire to leadership.
Note:Ccccccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,721

This is one of the reasons we’re biased toward local rather than global charities.
Note:POLITICA E POTERE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,726

advertise our prosocial orientation helps explain why, as a general rule, we do so little original research to determine where to donate.
Note:ALTRO MISTERO CHE CADE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,728

in order to signal how prosocial we are, we need to donate to charities that are publicly known to be worthy.
Note:COSA CI INTERESSA VERAMENTE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,733

There’s one final quality that charity allows us to advertise: the spontaneous, almost involuntary concern for the welfare of others.
Note:ALTRO PROSCIUTTO IN VETRINA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,735

“See how easily I’m moved to help others? When people near me are suffering, I can’t help wanting to make their situation better; it’s just who I am.”
Note:COSA STIAMO DICENDO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,737

it means you’ll make a great ally.

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,742

spontaneous giving demonstrates how little choice we have in the matter, how it’s simply part of our character
Note:ESSENZIALE LA SPONTANEITÀ X PUBBLICIZZARE IL NS CARATTERE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,743

This also helps explain why we respond to individual faces and stories more than we respond to dry statistics,
Note:LA SPONTANEITÀ SPIEGA TANTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,744

Paul Bloom,
Note:STUDIOSO DI EMPATIA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,746

“The mark of a civilized man is the capacity to read a column of numbers and weep,”
Note:BERTRAND RUSSELL

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,754

MISSING FORMS OF CHARITY
Note:Tttttttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,758

giving to people in the far future.
Note:ATTIVITÀ NEGLETTA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,758

Instead of donating money now, we might put it in a trust and let the magic of compound interest work for 50 or 500 years,
Note:CONTENUTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,759

These have been called “Methuselah trusts,” the most famous of which were set up by Benjamin Franklin.
Note:BATTESIMO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,760

he gave two gifts of ₤1,000 each to the cities of Boston and Philadelphia, and he instructed the funds to be invested for 100 years before being used to sponsor apprenticeships for local children.
Note:BF

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,763

helping people in the far future doesn’t showcase our empathy
Note:PURTROPPO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,766

“marginal charity.”65 Here the idea is to nudge our personal decisions just slightly (marginally) in the direction that’s beneficial to others.
Note:CARITÀ INVISIBILE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,771

if the developer built 11 stories instead of 10, it would reduce their profit by only a tiny amount, but it would add a bunch of new apartments to the neighborhood.
Note:ESEMPIO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,774

there’s no way to demonstrate to others that you’ve engaged in an act of marginal charity;
Note:L INCONVENIENTE IN QS CASI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,778

WRAPPING UP
Ttttttttttt

11 Art

11 Art
Note:11@@@@@@@@@@

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,121

painting cave

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,121

between 15,000 and 35,000 years ago.

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,122

earliest rock art appeared some 40,000 years ago.
Note:INDONESIA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,123

in South Africa, red ocher engravings
Note:100000

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,124

the use of red ocher as body paint

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,125

Art is also a human universal.4 Every human culture on the planet

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,126

painting, styling their hair, adorning their bodies, decorating their living spaces,

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,127

It’s a costly behavior, both in time and energy,5 but at the same time it’s impractical
Note:DILEMMA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,132

What Is Art?
Note:LASCIAMO PERDERE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,134

“essentially contested

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,135

why people make and enjoy art
Note:IL NS PROBL

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,145

“made special,”

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,146

for human attention and enjoyment.

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,150

while ecological selection (the pressure to survive) abhors waste, sexual selection often favors it.
Note:UNA BUONA DFINIZIONE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,151

we prefer mates who can afford to waste

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,152

survival surplus—health,

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,154

Adaptation or Evolutionary Byproduct?

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,155

bipedalism is an adaptation:

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,155

Our ability to read,
Note:COLLATERALE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,159

contributing to our biological fitness.
Note:ARTE COME ADATTAMENTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,160

Steven Pinker,

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,161

pleasurable but not particularly useful.

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,163

it’s a human universal:
Note:ARG X L ADATTIVITÀ

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,164

art is costly:
Note:SECONDO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,167

Finally, art is old enough, in evolutionary terms, for selection
Note:TERZO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,171

PARABLE OF THE BOWERBIRD
Note:tttttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,200

The male illustrates the virtue of the handicap principle.
Note:HANDICAP...PRODUTTORE...DIVISIONE NEI RUOLI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,206

Female bowerbirds, in turn, illustrate the importance of discernment in evaluating
Note:CONSUMATRICE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,208

shop around,

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,209

If a satin bowerbird population happens to live in a forest with an abundance of blue-colored objects, even a relatively unfit male might be able to muster a display that would be impressive in a blue-scarce environment.
Note:ESEMPIO DI DISCERNIMENTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,212

ART IN HUMANS
Note:tttttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,214

in our species, males don’t have a monopoly on making art—nor do females have a monopoly on enjoying it.
Note:DIFFERENZA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,217

males invest a lot in their offspring and, consequently, need to be choosy about their mates.
Note:LA COSA HA SENSO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,218

is more than just a courtship display,
Note:BIGGER DIFF

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,219

artist’s health, energy, vigor, coordination, and overall fitness.

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,222

Scheherazade uses her artful storytelling to stave off execution
Note:ESEMPIO DI USO ALTERNATIVO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,224

Intimidating rivals
Note:ALTRA FUNZIONE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,225

gangs tag walls to mark their territory)

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,226

use wit to humiliate hecklers).
Note:A TEATRO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,226

many reasons for wanting to impress
Note:UNO STRUMENTO CHE IMPRESSIONA...CAPACITÀ

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,227

human artists don’t need to be conscious

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,229

important isn’t whether we’re aware that we’re using art as a fitness display, but rather the fact that art works as a fitness display.
Note:DISCLAIMER

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,233

portraying beauty and inducing pleasure.
Note:GENERAL WINDSOM UNO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,234

self-expression or communicating
Note:DUE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,235

These functions aren’t mutually exclusive, nor are they incompatible with the fitness display theory.

Note | Location: 3,236

COMPATIBILI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,238

“showing off” is one of the important motives
Note:UNO DEI TANTI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,239

our artistic instincts have been shaped substantially by this motive.
Note:L ISTINTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,247

Intrinsic properties

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,248

perceptual properties.
Note:INTRINSECO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,249

everything visible on the canvas:
Note:ESEMPIO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,251

Extrinsic properties,

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,251

the consumer can’t perceive directly

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,252

who the artist is,

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,252

how many hours it took,

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,253

how expensive the materials

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,254

whether the artist copied the painting from a photograph. This is an extrinsic property

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,257

conventional view locates the vast majority of art’s value in its intrinsic properties,

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,258

Beauty, for example, is typically understood as an experience that arises from the artwork itself.
Note:BELLEZZA...INTRINSECA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,261

in the fitness-display theory, extrinsic properties are crucial

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,262

art is largely a statement about the artist, a proof of his or her virtuosity.

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,263

it’s often the extrinsic properties that make the difference
Note:LEGGI IL GIORNALE CHE PARLA D ARTE... IL TRIONFO DELL ESTRINSECO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,264

If a work of art is physically (intrinsically) beautiful, but was made too easily (like if a painting was copied from a photograph), we’re likely to judge it as much less valuable than a similar work that required greater skill to produce.
Note:ESEMPIO MUSICA ROBOTICA... COPIA DI UN DIPINTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,266

consumers appreciate the same artwork less when they’re told it was made by multiple artists
Note:ESEMPIO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,267

how much effort went into it,

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,273

replica museums don’t exist, and the idea strikes us as a bit silly
Note:REPLICA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,275

replicas strongly suggests that we often use art as something other than a trigger for sensory or intellectual experiences.
Note:TESI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,276

Mona Lisa,

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,279

80 percent of them said they’d prefer to see the ashes of the original rather than an indistinguishable replica.
Note:LE CENERI DELLA MONNALISA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,281

THE IMPORTANCE OF EXTRINSIC PROPERTIES
Note:ttttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,285

it might actually be a seashell. Did she just pick it up off the beach, or did she somehow make it herself?
Note:ESEMPIO DELL ESTRINSECO: ...LA SCULTURA CONCHIGLIOSA ERA UNA CONCHIGLIA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,286

This question is now absolutely central to your appreciation

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,287

thing on the pedestal is clearly pleasing to the eye. But its value as art hinges entirely on the artist’s technique. If she found it on the beach: meh.

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,290

is endemic to our experience of art.
Note:È NEL NOSTRO ISTINTO: LA BELLEZZA È SECONDARIA... UN PORTATO DELLA CIVILTÀ... L ESIBIZIONISMO È TUTTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,291

we care about more than the perceptual experience

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,292

Consider our emphasis on originality in works of art. We prize originality and spurn works that are too derivative,
Note:COPIARE UN TESTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,294

our concern for using art to evaluate the artist.
Note:NN CI INTERESSA L ARTE MA L ARTISTA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,296

“We find attractive,” says Miller, “those things that could have been produced only by people with attractive, high-fitness qualities such as health, energy, endurance, hand–eye coordination, fine motor control, intelligence, creativity,
Note:SOLO L ARTE CHE SEGNALA GRANDI DOTI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,299

using techniques that are more difficult or demanding, but which don’t improve the intrinsic properties
Note:LA RISPOSTA DELL ARTISTA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,301

to demonstrate their fitness by making something that lower-fitness competitors could not make,
Note:IMPORTANTE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,308

continue to relish live performances,
Note:LIVE E STUDIO... GLI AGGIUSTAMENTI... IL PHOTOSHOP

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,309

performing live is a handicap.

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,310

(e.g., lip synching is anathema)

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,311

improvised

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,312

the appeal of constraints in a given art form.
Note:ALTRO ELEMENTO: IL GENERE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,314

to patch up their mistakes with putty or glue.
Note:LO SCULTORE NN SI CORREGGE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,314

We enjoy art not in spite of the constraints that artists hold themselves to, but because those constraints
Note:FORMA E GENERI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,315

WHEN EXTRINSIC FACTORS CHANGE
Note:tttttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,322

lobster was literally low-class food,
Note:L ARAGOSTA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,322

harsh penal environment

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,324

how plentiful lobsters were in old New England.
Note:RAGIONE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,326

now it’s considered a delicacy,
Note:OGGI È PRELIBATA... PERCHÈ RARA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,327

aesthetic shift

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,327

skin color

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,328

suntanned skin was disdained as the mark of a low-status laborer.
Note:PRIMA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,330

only the wealthy could afford to lay around soaking in the

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,330

sun.35
Note:OGGI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,334

consumers unequivocally valued technical perfection
Note:PRIMA DELLA RIVOL IND... QUANDO TUTTO ERA FATTO A MANO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,335

prized for their realism,
Note:SCULTURE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,337

demonstrated the artist’s virtuosity
Note:REALISMO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,344

A vase, for example, could now be made smoother and more symmetric than ever before—but that very perfection became the mark of cheap, mass-produced goods.
Note:OGGI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,346

because of their imperfections.
Note:L APPREZZAMENTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,347

two spoons: an expensive, handmade silver spoon and a factory-made spoon cast from cheap aluminum.
Note:PARADOSSO DEL CUCCHIAIO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,349

consumers vastly prefer the silver spoon

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,350

silver is more beautiful than aluminum?

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,350

imagine showing the spoons to an untrained forager from the Amazonian forests,

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,353

aluminum spoon is made to a more exacting standard,

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,354

After attending to all the perceptual qualities of the two spoons, the forager might easily prefer the aluminum one.
Note:LA PREFERENZA PIÙ NATURALE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,356

The key facts, so relevant to modern consumers, are entirely extrinsic to the spoons. We know that aluminum is common and cheap,
Note:ESTRINS

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,358

factory-made goods are available to everyone, while only the wealthy

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,361

Painters could no longer hope to impress viewers
Note:DOPO LA FOTOGRAFIA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,363

impressionism, cubism, expressionism, surrealism, abstraction.
Note:NUOVI GENERI NVENTATI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,363

authenticity
Note:PIÚ IMP

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,363

representational
Note:MENO IMP

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,366

easier, but more precise, new techniques.
Note:ELEMENTO SPIAZZANTE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,367

digital cameras and photo-editing software.

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,367

electronic synthesizers and pitch correction.

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,371

Whenever we prefer things made “the old-fashioned way”—handwritten instead of printed, homemade instead of store-bought, live instead of prerecorded—we’re choosing to celebrate the skill and effort of an artist over the intrinsically superior results

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,374

Roman Mars

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,375

architectural movement characterized by its use of concrete.
Note:BRUTALISM...MODERNOSMO ESTREMO.CEMENTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,376

intrinsically cold, inhuman,
Note:GIUDIZIO POPOLARE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,379

requires a great deal of skill and finesse

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,379

Every little detail has to be calculated out in advance,

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,380

there’s no going back to make
Note:UNA VOLTA CHE IL CEMENTO SI VERSA

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,384

WHY ART IS IMPRACTICAL
Note:tttttttttr

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,387

however exquisite the knife’s craftsmanship, however pleasing it is to the senses, it doesn’t qualify as “art”
Note:UN COLTELLO PERFETTO...XCHÈ NN È ARTE?

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,388

fitness-display theory explains why.

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,389

advertise our survival surplus
Note:SCOPO DELL ARTE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,390

By distilling time and effort into something non-functional, an artist effectively says, “I’m so confident in my survival that I can afford to waste time and energy.”
Note:I MESSAGGIO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,391

waste is important.
Note:LO SPRECO È TUTTO IN CHI PUNTA SULL ISTINTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,397

Consider the difference between clothing, which is a necessity, and fashion, which is a luxury.
Note:MODA E ABBIGLIAMENTO... TITTO BEN VISOBILE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,402

High heels,

Note | Location: 3,402

TACCHI

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,402

awkward for walking and brutal on the feet—which

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,403

“I care about fashion.”

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,403

Neckties

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,404

cotton or denim,
Note:QUEL CHE DURA È BRITTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,405

silk, lace, or wool.

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,405

polyester?

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,406

Food—as an art form—also needs to distinguish
Note:CIBO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,406

more than mere nourishment

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,408

Haute cuisine

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,408

artful arrangement

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,410

None of these especially improves the taste,

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,411

DISCERNMENT

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,412

discernment—the skill of the savvy consumer
Note:CRITICO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,413

“Which way is high status?”
Note:LA DOMANDA DELL ANIMALE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,413

Like the female bowerbird,

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,416

consume a lot of art
Note:COME CHI CERCA MAROTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,417

common

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,418

rare

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,418

An untrained ear can’t appreciate the genius of Bach.

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,419

feel the pea beneath 20 mattresses

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,422

We spend an incredible amount of our leisure time refining our critical faculties
Note:ANCHE DISCERNERE È UN ARTE

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,424

We’re eager to evaluate art, reflect on it, criticize it, calibrate our criticisms

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,429

We don’t want others to know that we’re inept at telling good art from bad,

Yellow highlight | Location: 3,430

we evaluate each other not only for our first-order skills, but for our skills at evaluating the skills of others.