HL 3—Overcoming disagreement

3—Overcoming disagreement
Note:3@@@@@@@@

Yellow highlight | Location: 605

The overwhelming benefits of economic growth help us resolve clashing preferences,
Note:TESI...RICCHEZZA E TOLLERANZA

Yellow highlight | Location: 619

Arrow’s impossibility theorem makes it impossible to resolve clashes of preference.
Note:X MOLTI STUDIOSI

Yellow highlight | Location: 620

But once we consider happiness and well-being as relevant features for comparing one choice to another, Arrow’s impossibility theorem does not hold.
Note:MA ECVO COASE

Yellow highlight | Location: 623

Once a richer information set is introduced, the standard impossibility theorems fade away,
Note:CON IL DENARO LA CARDINALITÀ PRENDE IL POSTO DELL ORDINALITÀ...X QS IL GENIALE TEOREMA È POCO CONSIDERATO

Yellow highlight | Location: 624

never a big problem in the real world
Note:L IMPOSSIBILITÀ RESTA SOLO IN CASI LIMITE

Yellow highlight | Location: 640

Preferences as expressed in the marketplace often appear irrational, intransitive, spiteful, or otherwise morally dubious, as evidenced by a wide range of vices, from cravings for refined sugar to pornography
Note:IL DESIDERIO È UN BUON BUONA NDICATORE DEL BENE?

Yellow highlight | Location: 643

in many cases it seems obvious that satisfying preferences does not make people happier
Note:Ccccccccccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 644

Focusing on the long-term benefits of growth sidesteps such dilemmas.
Note:X FORTUNA

Yellow highlight | Location: 644

A fast-food cheeseburger is not actually worth $4.89, considering its potential impact on my future health.
Note:ESEMPIO

Yellow highlight | Location: 646

Yet at the same time, living in a much wealthier society—even one rife with fast food—is still good for most people, including good for their health.
Note:Cccccccccccccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 648

life expectancy is still rising with wealth.
Note:ANCHE SE SONO TUTTI TOTTI BESI

Yellow highlight | Location: 649

comparisons become quite obvious after the passage of enough time.
Note:NEL LUNGO I VANTAGI SONO EVIDENTI

Yellow highlight | Location: 657

To sum this all up, if we make a broad enough and long enough comparison, we will find that for a lot of choices the aggregation problems are not all that serious, at least not cripplingly so.
Note:RIASSUNTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 659

The Principle of Growth
Note:Tttttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 664

the East Asian economic miracles, which includes Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Singapore, and China
Note:LA CRESCITA COME VALORE...UN CASO N AMBIGUO

Yellow highlight | Location: 670

The Principle of Growth Plus Rights:
Note:Ttttttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 670

Inviolable human rights,
Note:UN LIMITE ALLE POLITICHE DI CRESCITA

Yellow highlight | Location: 671

a narrowly utilitarian approach.
Note:RESPINTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 676

Philosopher Robert Nozick wrote of rights as “side constraints.”
Note:L SPIRATORE...IL VINCOLO

Yellow highlight | Location: 677

these side constraints need not coincide with Nozick’s libertarian vision,
Note:NON ASSOLUTIZZIAMO....TASSE E PROP...TUTTO DA CONCILIARE CON LA CRESCITA

Yellow highlight | Location: 680

virtually everyone believes in rights of some sort,
Note:INUTILE MASCHERARE

Yellow highlight | Location: 682

notions of “positive rights” or “positive liberties”—both
Note:INCOMPATIBILI CON I DIRITTI CHE HO IN MENTE

Yellow highlight | Location: 683

positive liberties is important, but it is already covered by the imperative to maximize sustainable growth.
Note:PRECISAZIONE....NN CONTEGGIAMO DUE VOLTE

Yellow highlight | Location: 686

various forms of murder, torture, and abuse.
Note:COSA HO IN MENTE

Yellow highlight | Location: 686

we should violate rights to prevent extremely negative outcomes
Note:ECCEZIONE

Yellow highlight | Location: 687

end of the world,
Note:Ccccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 690

postulated rights are not quite absolute,
Note:CcccccccccccccTROLLEY

Yellow highlight | Location: 692

Aren’t there other exceptions to the rules?
Note:Ttttttttttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 697

let’s consider one of Derek Parfit’s “Mistakes in Moral Mathematics.”
Note:ACROSTICO

Yellow highlight | Location: 698

if a firing squad of six shooters kills an innocent person, all of them firing accurately at his heart, can we say that any one of the shooters is a murderer? After all, the “marginal product”
Note:TUTTI SPARANO ALLA STESSA XSONA

Yellow highlight | Location: 700

Does it matter whose bullet arrived first?
Note:Ttttttttttttt

Yellow highlight | Location: 704

both human rights deontology and a rule consequentialist approach point us in the right direction,
Note:DIRITTI E DETERRENZA...SOLUZIONE UNIVOCA

Yellow highlight | Location: 706

more murders would be carried out by large groups so that no single individual would be liable.
Note:ANCHE IL CONSEGUENZIALISMO SI ACCORDA CON I DIRITTI

Yellow highlight | Location: 709

Maybe a single act of corruption has no harmful effects,
Note:ESEMPI PIÙ REALISTICI

Yellow highlight | Location: 713

Numerous violations of the rule or law may seem harmless enough,
Note:VALANGA E PALLE DI NEVE

Yellow highlight | Location: 725

Once we move beyond absolute human rights and work toward a Crusonia plant (in this case, sustainable economic growth), most of the remaining morality will be practical in nature,
Note:PRAGMATISMO

Yellow highlight | Location: 729

If the time horizon is sufficiently long, the only non-growth–related values that will bind practical decisions are the absolute side constraints, or the inviolable human rights.
Note:CONCLUSIONE

Yellow highlight | Location: 731

the dual ideals of prosperity and liberty will be central to ethics.
Note:Cccccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 732

“Growth and Human Rights.”
Note:LA FORMULA

Yellow highlight | Location: 737

“potential compensation” principle
X SUPERARE ARROW