lunedì 26 novembre 2018

HL 4 DOGMA

4 DOGMA
Note:4@@@@@@@@@@@@@

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,169
it be really true that men sickened of sacred words and wearied of theology, if this largely unreasoning irritation against “dogma” did arise out of some ridiculous excess of such things among priests in the past, then I fancy we must be laying up a fine crop of cant for our descendants to grow tired of.
Note:CHESTRTON IL DOGMA COME IL GRANO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,173
The dawn of the Enlightenment,
Note:FINE DEI DOGMI....SECONDO LA VULGATA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,175
The war on dogma
Note:L IMPERATIVO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,176
Descartes, for instance, attempted to purge his mind of any and all notions,
Note:SOLO L EVIDENZA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,179
delegitimizing the authority of the past to be among their noblest endeavors.
Note:IL NOBILE INTENTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,180
Dogmas are ideals broken in by time and consecrated by experience.
Note:L ORIGINE DEL DOGMA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,186
The dogma of the czars killed thousands. But the dogmas of Marxism, dressed in the uniform of science and reason, slaughtered and enslaved hundreds of millions.
Note:DOGMI VS DOGMI

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,187
Hitler was obsessed with the need to throw off the dogmas of Christianity’s slave morality.
Note:L OSSESSIONE DI H

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,188
“Christianity, of course, has reached the peak of absurdity,” Hitler insisted in 1941. “And that’s why one day its structure will collapse. Science has already impregnated humanity. Consequently, the more Christianity clings to its dogmas, the quicker it will decline.”
Note:DA UN DISCORSO DI H

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,196
they uncritically embrace an equally dogmatic aversion to mass murder.
Note:IL NS DOGMA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,198
“dogma”: “seems good.”
Note:EVIDENZA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,199
we must shed humanity of its humanity.
Note:QUEL CHE SI PROCLAMA DI FATTO DICHIARANDO GUERRA AI DOGMI

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,199
animal that makes dogmas.
Note:L UOMO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,202
When [man] drops one doctrine after another in a refined skepticism,
Note:IL DOGMA UNICA ARMA CONTRO LO SCETTICISMO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,205
Trees have no dogmas. Turnips are singularly broad-minded.
Note:CHI NM HA DOGMI SI FA PORTARE DAL VENTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,207
Jack Kevorkian.
Note:ARRUOLATI NELLA GUERRA CONTRO IL DOGMA 1

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,209
Franz Boas
Note:2

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,210
John Kenneth Galbraith
Note:3

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,211
Stephen Jay Gould,
Note:5

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,213
New York Times columnist Anthony Lewis
Note:6…IL NS NEMICO HA DELLE CERTEZZE

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,214
ertainty is the enemy of decency and humanity in people who are sure they are right, like Osama bin Laden and John Ashcroft.”
Note:PROCLAMA DI LEWIS

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,216
Lewis’s conclusion raises a simple question: “Is Lewis really sure about this?”
Note:GIOCO DI SPECCHI

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,216
you’re certain that certainty is evil,
Note:CORTO CIRCUITO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,217
this is dangerous nonsense.
Note:Ccccccccccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,221
men have invented philosophy precisely because they find change, chance and process too much for them, and desire infallible security and certainty.”
Note:IL RUOLO DELLA FILOSOFIA...DARE CERTEZZE

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,242
Science and reason are hailed as the greatest antidotes to dogma
Note:L ANTIDOTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,246
It is true that many dogmas are built upon mistakes. But that doesn’t mean the resulting edifice is not worthwhile.
Note:L EDIFICIO E LE FONDAMENTA....LA RAGIONE STRAUSSIANA...SE CI CREDI LO FAI...LA FORZA DELLA FEDE

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,248
Columbus “discovered” America by mistake and the world is better for what was built upon that mistake.
Note:COSTRUIRE SU UN ERRORE

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,249
How many beloved children were born thanks to some capricious accident?
Note:L ERRORE PIÙ BELLO DELLA VITA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,249
monogamous marriage between a man and a woman was a mistake, unchartered by the laws of evolution and unlicensed by the conclusions of science.
Note:UNA CIVILTÀ SU UNA COSA CHE DIAMO X SCONTATO........MORALE...NN CRITICARE I DOGMI PROPONI I TUOI E METTILI ALLA PROVA...LA SELEZIONE NATURALE FARÀ IL RESTO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,257
In his triumph Lincoln not only forged a new conception of our nation free of slavery, he forged a new dogma
Note:DOGMA ANTI SCHIAVISTA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,260
The only plausible utilitarian retort is that the many could not be happy while enjoying the fruits of slave labor.
Note:UTILITARISMO E SCHIAVISMO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,265
William F. Buckley understood that dogma is a source of progress because it sets boundaries of acceptable discourse.
Note:DGMA COME CONFINE

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,272
Science is the author of infinite boons to humanity and need not be put in the dock because it is also the accomplice to countless crimes.
Note:LE ACCUSE AI DOGMI SI POSSONO FARE ANCHE ALLA SCIENZA....SALVO POI PARLARE DI FALSA SCIENZA O FALSI DOGMI

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,276
Science is silent on what should be done with the fruits of science.
Note:LA SCIENZA NN IDEOLOGIZZATA IN SCIENTISMO È SILENTE SULL ESSENZIALE

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,276
Science can cure illnesses and cause them, destroy cities and build them, save lives and take them.
Note:TUTTO È POSSIBILE...LA SCIENZA È MEZZO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,279
Dogma constrains how science should be done.
Note:IL DOGMA DOMA NDIRIZZA LA SCIENZA...È FINE X IL MEZZO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,279
Hippocratic Oath, even in its original form, represents not a triumph of science but a triumph of moral absolutism.
Note:GIURAMENTO DI IPPOCRATE...NON È SCIENZA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,281
There’s nothing within science per se that says medical researchers must not experiment on human subjects;
Note:UOMO CAVIA...PERCHÈ NO?

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,283
The mandate “first do no harm” is as rankly ideological and dogmatic a precept
Note:IL DOGMA MEDICO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,285
Doctors make no such exceptions to the Hippocratic Oath—save, of course, when it comes to abortion—and only then when another dogmatic obsession trumps their oath.
Note:SCNTRO TRA DOGMI IN CAMPO MEDICO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,290
green religious devotion runs so deep that adherents to the dogma of climate change must not only subscribe to the diagnosis of a fevered earth, they must show undying loyalty to the proposed remedy as well.
Note:ALTRO INCROCIO XICOLOSO TRA DOGMI

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,293
How much of a contribution and how big a problem are still open questions,
Note:PRIMA INCERTEZZA CHE FA SALTARE I NERVI...VERO IL RISCALDAMENTO...PROB VERO L ANTROPICO MA...

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,294
It is also unclear what the ratio of costs and benefits might be.
Note:SECONDA INCERTEZZA CHE TFA SALTARE I NERVI

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,295
What gets less play are the potential benefits.
Note:SENTIAMO PARLARE SOLO DEI COSTI

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,297
“net cereal crop yields likely will increase by 5 to 20 percent,
Note:ES

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,297
United States as a whole will enjoy modest economic benefits
Note:Ccccccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,298
“growing season has lengthened an average of two days per decade
Note:USA E CANADA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,299
New sea routes, primarily through the Northwest Passage, will be opened as well.
Note:ALTRO BENEFICIO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,303
it is entirely possible that we could cure the earth by treating the symptom by, say, releasing particles into the air that would alleviate the greenhouse effect.
Note | Location: 1,304
TERZA VERITÀ CHE FA IMBESTIALIRE LE CURE...GEOENGENIRING?

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,305
geoengineering
Note:A CHI LO PROPOSE MAL GLIENE INCOLSE

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,308
what is lost in these debates is the crucial distinction between science and scientism.
Note:LA DISTINZIONE XDUTA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,308
value-neutral enterprise
Note:LA SCIENZA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,310
It is not the source of moral truths,
Note:LA SCIENZA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,313
Scientism, meanwhile, is the act of seeing in science what is not there.
Note:COS È LO SCIENTISMO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,314
The practitioners of scientism presume to tell us that we should live a certain way because science tells us we must.
Note:LA PRETESA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,316
It is the ancient naturalistic fallacy updated with more contemporary lingo.
Note:Cccccccccccc

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,317
Scientism is not a testable proposition; it is an assertion of faith.
Note:DOGMA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,318
scientific socialists, technocrats, progressives, social psychiatrists, and environmentalists insist that science is on their side
Note:MULLAH E ZELOTI DEL NS TEMPO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,320
“Back off man, I’m a scientist.”
Note:SLOGAN...BILL MURRAY IN GHOSTBUSTER

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,321
The fallacy of scientism creates priests
Note:ALMENO LA FALLACIA NATURALISTA SI ASTIENE

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,322
The fetus is an unhuman with no more rights than a ham sandwich
Note:DOGMA SCIENTISTA

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,324
This is nothing new. When man loses God he sets about to make new gods.
Note:TUTTO È SPIEGABILE...ERIC VOEGELIN

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,325
when the symbols of transcendent religiosity are banned, new symbols develop from the inner-worldly language
Note:PAROLE DI VOEGELIN

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,327
man creates dogmas because man needs dogmas.
Note:OVVIO

Yellow highlight | Location: 1,329
“The mind cannot support moral chaos for long.
JOHN DOS PASSOS

domenica 25 novembre 2018

sabato 24 novembre 2018

LE MIE ERESIE

LE MIE ERESIE

Il mia fede già precaria è per giunta “sfregiata” da due eresie, entrambe derivano da una certa allergia al tomismo:

1) Con tutta la buona volontà, faccio fatica a pensare ad un Dio “semplice” che si colloca fuori dal tempo. In altre parole, non riesco a pregare un “triangolo”, ho bisogno di credere in una “persona”.

2) Vedo qualcosa di radicale nella libertà umana, qualcosa che limita persino l’onniscienza divina. Rendendoci liberi Dio si limita.

Il combinato disposto delle due eresie facilita l'irruzione del miracolo: il Dio sorpreso dall’uomo – dalle sue azioni, dalla sua sofferenza, dalla sua felicità - deve talvolta intervenire nel mondo per cambiare le cose. Inutile aggiungere che ogni intervento divino equivale a un miracolo.

MIRACOLI

MIRACOLI
Non si può credere nei miracoli se non si crede nel soprannaturale. Voi credete nel soprannaturale? Per esempio, credete che esistano i pensieri? E che esiste la mente? Se credete alla mente e ai pensieri, allora credete nel soprannaturale e avrete fatto il primo passo per credere nei miracoli. Dirò di più, la presenza stessa del pensiero razionale è già di per sè un miracolo.
Il punto debole dei naturalisti è che erano talmente impegnati a pensare alla natura che non hanno prestato attenzione al fatto che stessero pensando.

flusso greg ip

flusso jonah goldberg

flusso c.s. lewis

LA MORALITA’ DEL PRAGMATISTA

LA MORALITA’ DEL PRAGMATISTA
Il naturalista pragmatico ha problemi con i giudizi morali, si tratta delle medesime difficoltà sollevate nel suo schema da qualsiasi altro tipo di pensiero. Per lui ogni giudizio è viziato da illusioni di natura… chimica. Per lui la parola "devo" ha la stessa valenza dell'espressione "ho voglia". Che torturare un bambino sia sbagliato non può essere più “vero” di uno sbadiglio o della nausea. Fortunatamente, se lo dimentica subito e questo è il suo pregio maggiore. Cosa significa che “se lo dimentica subito”? Significa che un momento dopo aver riconosciuto che bene e male sono illusioni ci esorterà a lavorare per i posteri, a educare i nostri bambini, a rivoluzionare la società, a liberarci dai tiranni e a vivere e morire per il bene della razza umana. E questo anche se a freddo è pronto a riconoscere quanto il suo impulso a essere utile ai posteri equivalga alla sua golosità per il formaggio. Non sembra turbato dal fatto che se il lunedì distrugge la mia venerazione per la coscienza non puo’ aspettarsi di ritrovarmi in venerazione il martedì.