8   BLAME Blamestorming and the Moral of the Financial Crisis
                    
                            
                                Note:8@@@@@@@@
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,014
        
            Persian Empire
                
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,022
        
            How can a video game trick me into thinking that it is a person? I went into a store and paid money for a disk, which I stuck into a box of bolts attached to a video screen.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:BIAS...DA VIDEOGIOCO....QUI SI RACCONTA LA STORIA DI COME SI FINISCE X INSULTARE UN VIDEOGIOCO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,025
        
            Our brains are wired to look for agency everywhere.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:ERRORE DELL ATTRIBUZIONE...SE QUALCOSA FA QUALCOSA È XCHÈ VUOLE FARLA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,026
        
            HOW WE SEE THE WORLD
                
                    
                            
                                Note:Tttttttttttt
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,029
        
            “What we thought was hard, things like playing chess, turned out to be easy, and what we thought was easy, things like recognizing faces or objects, which a child can do, that turned out to be much harder.”
                
                    
                            
                                Note:IL PROBLEMA IA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,035
        
            Have you looked for hidden pictures in the wallpaper of your childhood bedroom, or faces in the clouds?
                
                    
                            
                                Note:OSSESSIONE BEN NOTA DI SCOVARE VOLTI
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,036
        
            That’s your pattern recognition software calling order out of chaos.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:Cccccccccc
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,038
        
            What I described isn’t exactly what you saw, is it? You probably saw a white triangle
                
                    
                            
                                Note:GIOCHINO VISUALE...GUARDA LA FIGURA NEL LIBRO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,040
        
            In our natural environment,
                
                    
                            
                                Note:CI SONO TRIANGOLI NON CUNEI.....ECCO SPIEGATO XCHÈ VEDI QUEL CHE VEDI
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,043
        
            “Coincidence avoidance”
                
                    
                            
                                Note:REGOLA DEL SISTEMA VISIVO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,044
        
            If you show people an animated movie of one ball running into another and stopping, while the other ball rolls away, they will say that the first ball made the second one move.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:NOI VEDIAMO CAUSE VUNQUE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,048
        
            Albert Michotte
                
                    
                            
                                Note:L ESPERTO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,049
        
            People described balls on a screen as “hitting,” “chasing,” and “following”
                
                    
                            
                                Note:ESPERIMENTO REALE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,052
        
            “We also seek out patterns in events,” says the scientist Bruce Hood in his recent book, SuperSense. “Our mind design forces us to see organization
                
                    
                            
                                Note:ALTRO BIAS CONNESSO CON QS
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,057
        
            when unexpected disasters do occur, our intuitions push us to see a person and a plan, rather than some complex impersonal force. We start looking, in short, for someone to blame.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:UNA FORMA MOLTOL PARTICOLARE DEL BIAS....ANTIDOTO LA PREGHIERA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,058
        
            THE “TRUTH” BEHIND THE CALAMITY
                
                    
                            
                                Note:Tttttt
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,059
        
            A few years back, I found myself embroiled in a long e-mail exchange with a 9/11 Truther.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:ESPERIENZA XSONALE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,064
        
            government is neither evil nor competent enough to have orchestrated the biggest terrorist attack
                
                    
                            
                                Note:LA SEMPLICE VERITÀ
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,076
        
            “Okay, so it’s a controlled demolition,” says Asner.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:LA VERSIONE DI MOLTI TRUTHER
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,078
        
            Controlled demolitions cannot be engineered and rigged in a day. It takes months.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:IL PROBLEMA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,087
        
            no one reported noticing a team of demolition experts doing any such thing.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:CONTRO LA TESI COMPLOTTISTA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,097
        
            It wouldn’t have been that hard for the government to pull it off, came the response.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:FATTI FUORI I TESTIMONI...LA RISPOSTA SEMPRE PRONTA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,103
        
            By now I was muttering to myself and kicking my desk as I typed. I replied that I didn’t understand why explosives would have caused the site to burn for months.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:LA DISCUSSIONE TI INFIAMMA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,107
        
            His views were essentially unfalsifiable;
                
                    
                            
                                Note:MORALE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,118
        
            Commercial airliners simply could not have generated either the force, or the heat, needed to bring those buildings down.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:ALTRO ARGOMENTO COMPLOTTISTA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,119
        
            refueling tankers, or perhaps cruise missiles.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:ALTERNATIVE PROPOSTE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,120
        
            distract your eye
                
                    
                            
                                Note:IL RUOLO DEGLI AEREI IN UN COMPLOTTOSMO ALTENATIVO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,121
        
            high explosives, possibly placed there years before.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:LA CAUSA REALE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,131
        
            “What’s so interesting is that the Truthers never do this: picking up the phone, talking to actual experts—they
                
                    
                            
                                Note:COSA NN FANNO MAI I PSEUDO-ESPERTI
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,134
        
            how the claims were assembled in the first place. They ranged from basic misunderstanding to seizing on early erroneous reporting.”
                
                    
                            
                                Note:ORIGINE DELLA TEORIA COMPLOTTISTA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,142
        
            Instead of being happy to learn that their government probably hadn’t orchestrated
                
                    
                            
                                Note:REAZIONE SORPRENDENTE...SI RESTA AFFEZIONATI ALLA PRIMA IMPRESSIONE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,152
        
            I KNOW THERE’S A VILLAIN IN THERE SOMEWHERE
                
                    
                            
                                Note:Ttttttt
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,155
        
            According to this theory, easy money from the Federal Reserve, and massive government backing for the mortgage market, caused a credit boom that drove markets to unsustainable heights.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:LE DUE NARRAZIONI DELLA CRISI....QUELLA DI DESTRA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,158
        
            Then there were the Moochers: people who took too much risk because they knew that if push came to shove, the government would bail them out.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:Ccccccccc
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,166
        
            For starters, many of the banks that went bust did so in part because they had been “eating their own toxic waste”:
                
                    
                            
                                Note:QUALCHE PROBLEMA FATTUALE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,169
        
            Spain, for example, has no Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac to lend
                
                    
                            
                                Note:ALTRO PROBLEMA FATTUALE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,173
        
            And yet Spain’s housing bubble was even worse
                
                    
                            
                                Note:Ccccccccccf
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,178
        
            crazy free market ideologues persuaded Congress and the president to deregulate
                
                    
                            
                                Note:VERSIONE SINISTRORSA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,179
        
            stealing from the poor and gullible by selling outrageously oversize mortgages to financial naïfs
                
                    
                            
                                Note:LA VOGLIA MATTA DI PIAZZARE MUTUI A TUTTI
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,182
        
            This narrative, like the conservative version, has its share of problems. For one thing, the financial naïfs weren’t all that naïve. “During the great housing bubble and bust, journalists spent a fair amount of time searching for the perfect mortgage victim,” writes David Leonhardt,
                
                    
                            
                                Note:PRIMO PROBLEMA FATTUALE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,192
        
            Progressives have nominated a few regulations—notably, the Gramm–Leach–Bliley Act of 1999, which repealed one of the last remnants of the 1933 Glass–Steagall Act, a ban on commercial banks owning investment banks. If the crisis had originated in hybrid firms like JPMorgan, which had both commercial banking and investment banking arms, this might be more convincing. But it didn’t. JPMorgan was fine—in
                
                    
                            
                                Note:BITTER FRUIT DI QUELLA MOSSA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Note | Location: 3,195
        
            ALTRO PROBLEMA
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,196
        
            investment banks like Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers, and Merrill Lynch—the
                
                    
                            
                                Note:Ccccccccccc
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,200
        
            Neither of these narratives is all wrong—there
                
                    
                            
                                Note:SIA CHIARO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,204
        
            What’s even more striking is that at bottom, they are the same story: everything used to be great, then some greedy fool changed the rules and ruined everything.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:IL MCD...LA PRESENZA DEL CATTIVO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,206
        
            Christopher Foote, Kristopher Gerardi, and Paul Willen of the Fed
                
                    
                            
                                Note:CHI HA CERCATO UNA SPIEGAZIONE DIFFERENTE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,208
        
            The financial crisis happened for the stupidest reason imaginable—no one thought that housing prices would fall as much as they did.
                
        
                Note | Location: 3,209
        
            LA CAUSA REALE
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,213
        
            they didn’t believe it would happen.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:UNA NOTA ACCURATA DI LEHMAN DEL 2005
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,221
        
            price credit risk
                
                    
                            
                                Note:OPERAZIONE DIFFICILE DOVE SPESSO SI SBAGLIA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,233
        
            Bankers were hardly the only people who thought they were geniuses who could turn guesses into gold. Entire academic careers were founded on what we used to call “the great moderation”: the idea that improved management of the money supply and the banking system by the Federal Reserve had essentially tamed the business cycle
                
                    
                            
                                Note:NN AVIDITÀ MA GNORANZA E ABUSO NELLA CONOSCENZA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,240
        
            FINANCIAL GROUPIDITY
                
                    
                            
                                Note:Ttttttttttt
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,242
        
            they had no idea this was coming.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:BANCHE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,242
        
            guilty of insufficient imagination:
                
                    
                            
                                Note:NN AVIDITÀ
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,243
        
            people basically shrugged and said, “If it gets that bad, we’re all so completely screwed that there’s no point planning for it.”
                
                    
                            
                                Note:AVVITATI
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,245
        
            bad positive feedback loops:
                
                    
                            
                                Note:ERRORI CHE MONTANO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,246
        
            Vernon Smith,
                
                    
                            
                                Note:CHI LI HA STUDIATI IN LABORATORIO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,249
        
            Smith and his team were looking to see how prices emerged, but they found something unexpected: they got bubbles. Every time.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:REGOLA DELLA BOLLA...ESPERIMENTI CON LE MATRICOLE IN LABORATORIO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,253
        
            Only when you run it a third time do people start recognizing what is happening, and stop blowing bubbles.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:REGOLA DEL TRE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,258
        
            they underestimated the probability that the bubble would pop.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:RIPETIAMO LA SPIEGAZIONE DI FOOT
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,260
        
            they lost so much money in the crash.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:LA PROVA REGINA CHE L IGNORANZA SIA LA SPIEGA GIUSYA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,260
        
            Fuld, the head of Lehman, is reported to have lost a billion dollars, and was forced to sell off his $25 million New York City apartment
                
                    
                            
                                Note:UN ESEMPIO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,264
        
            Dick Fuld was forced out of the top slot at Lehman in a humiliating debacle, and has lost most of the wealth he gained over the course of his career in finance. That’s not fun, even if you’re still rich.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:ANCORA RICCO MA...
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,268
        
            how often do you see it advanced in an op-ed, or pushed by a talking head on television news?
                
                    
                            
                                Note:LA TEORIA DELL IGNORANZA NN È COOL
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,270
        
            THE AGENCY DETECTION MACHINE
                
                    
                            
                                Note:Tttttttttt
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,271
        
            Bruce Hood,
                
                    
                            
                                Note:STUDIOSO DEL CERVELLO INFANTILE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,272
        
            There are no random events
                
                    
                            
                                Note:CARATTERISTICHE DEL CERVELLO INFANTILE...1
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,273
        
            Things are caused by intention.
                
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,274
        
            Complexity cannot happen spontaneously
                
                    
                            
                                Note:2...3
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,275
        
            “agency-detection device.”
                
                    
                            
                                Note:IL NOME DEL MECANISMO CHE SI ATTIVA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,278
        
            One night not long ago, I spent five minutes trying to sneak up on my coat rack. I was alone in the house, and from the top of my stairs, the coat rack looked terrifyingly like a burglar surveying the booty.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:SAPETE CSA MI È CAPITATO IERI?
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,281
        
            It is probably not very dangerous to mistake a rock for a saber-toothed tiger, but it is very dangerous indeed to mistake a tiger for a rock.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:L ANTENATO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,285
        
            Walter Olson calls “blamestorming.”
                
                    
                            
                                Note:LO STUDIOSO CHE BATTEZZA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,290
        
            Why do we need to do this?
                
                    
                            
                                Note:TROVARE UN CAPRO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,294
        
            the number of people who think that by suggesting it, I am doing something reprehensible.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:CHI PROPONE LA CASUALITÀ È COMPLICE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,299
        
            we tend to see culprits rather than complexity.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:RIBADIAMO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,299
        
            look for intention instead of randomness,
                
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,300
        
            causation instead of chaos.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:Ccccccccc
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,300
        
            If nature abhors a vacuum, human reason abhors a coincidence.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:MOTTO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,300
        
            parents with autistic children became convinced that the vaccines their children had been given were causing it. The age at which autism is usually diagnosed is also the age at which kids in most Western countries are going through a heavy vaccination schedule.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:ALTRO ESEMPIO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,304
        
            we also tend to favor small, concrete stories over large ones. “Vaccines cause autism” has a lot more resonance than “some unspecified combination of environmental pollutants, infectious agents, and/or genetics is causing autism.”
                
                    
                            
                                Note:CCCCCCCCCC
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,309
        
            no one wants to be at the mercy of the universe.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:VOGLIA DI CONTROLLO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,312
        
            a universe where bad things sometimes happen
                
                    
                            
                                Note:L ALTERNATIVA AL CATTIVO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,313
        
            THE ILLUSION OF CONTROL
                
                    
                            
                                Note:Ttttttttttttt
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,315
        
            TO CROSS STREET PUSH BUTTON
                
                    
                            
                                Note:ILLUSIONE CHE TRANQUILLIZZA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,317
        
            Longtime New Yorkers sort of suspected that they didn’t do anything. And still, they pushed. Dinner parties were riven by debates worthy of the Reformation over those buttons
                
                    
                            
                                Note:IL PULSANTE DEI SEMAFORI
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,319
        
            people who had been pushing those buttons for decades swore that the light turned after.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:HIHIHI
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,321
        
            the buttons had been disconnected decades before.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:LA CONFERMA DEL NYT
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,326
        
            continued toward the button
                
                    
                            
                                Note:MA LA GENTE...
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,327
        
            “Just in case,”
                
                    
                            
                                Note:LA GIUSTIFICA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,328
        
            Ellen Langer has dubbed the illusion of control:
                
                    
                            
                                Note:IL BHATTESIMO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,332
        
            less stress if they believe
                
                    
                            
                                Note:BENEFICI
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,337
        
            low-ranking civil servants are much more likely to die
                
                    
                            
                                Note:I SUBORDINATI CREPANO PRIMA...NN CONTROLLANO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,344
        
            how much control you had over your workday,
                
                    
                            
                                Note:VARIABILE CHIAVE.... L IMPREVISTO TI AMMAZZA
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,352
        
            Finding someone to blame
                
                    
                            
                                Note:CI FA BENE MA NN RISOLVE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,354
        
            SCAPEGOATS AND THE RUSH TO JUDGMENT
                
                    
                            
                                Note:Tttttttttttt
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,358
        
            DNA testing
                
                    
                            
                                Note:LA SCOPERTA DI MOLTI ERRORI GIUDIZIARI
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,370
        
            stranger rapes, the assault or murder
                
                    
                            
                                Note:PIÙ UN CRIMINE È ORROBILE PIÙ CRESCONO LE POSSIBILITÀ DI ERRORE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,371
        
            lot of pressure to find the perpetrator.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:CAUSA PROB DEGLI ERRORI
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,378
        
            Once they’re focused, they stop “looking for suspects”
                
                    
                            
                                Note:QUEL CHE SUCCEDE ALL INVTIGATORE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,381
        
            extraordinarily prone to confirmation bias.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:TIPICO
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,393
        
            Why do hard-line law-and-order prosecutors fight so hard against groups like the Innocence Project? The project does DNA testing at its own expense; it costs the taxpayer nothing. And many times they end up affirming the prosecution’s case.
                
                    
                            
                                Note:UNA GUERRA INSPIEGABILE
                            
                    
                
            
        
                Yellow highlight | Location: 3,408
        
            “It’s staggering how organized they think the world is,”
                
                    
                            
                                COME VEDE I CATTIVI IL COMPLOTTISTA